From Fandom to Feminism: An Analysis of the Zine Press By Heath RowThroughout most of the history of the United States,
the periodical press has held a prominent position in mainstream
American society. Starting with the insurgence of popular magazines
in the late 1700s, periodicals have existed almost as long as
the United States itself and have established a foothold in the
hearts and minds of the American people, maintaining an overwhelming
presence in today's culture. Magazines have
evolved substantially over time, their content becoming more
focused and appealing to select audiences. Yet there are still
thousands of magazines that go unnoticed because of their underground
nature. This invisible press is not composed merely of specialized
trade publications known only within certain professional strata
but has sparked an independent magazine revolution of sorts,
bringing zines to the forefront as the primary actors in this
insurrection. At its most basic
level, the word "zine" is derived from "fanzine,"
a contraction of fan magazine. [Wertham] But zines, like their
mainstream periodical counterparts, have changed considerably,
and the historic definitional connotations attached to the word
"fanzine" have become too limiting. Instead of focusing
solely on fandom (a collectivity of fans) and pop culture, today's
zines encompass many aspects of the periodical press, including
the modern underground press spawned by the alternative newspapers
of the 1960s, magazines such as Mother Jones and the Nation,
the small press of literary and poetry magazines and, still,
the fandom press that services music, science fiction and comic
book enthusiasts. [Gunderloy, 1992] In fact, the definition
of fanzines has expanded somewhat to describe magazines produced
by and for fans of science fiction, popular music, sports and
other topical subjects, but an overwhelming lack of study in
this field has also added to the difficulty of accurately defining
zines. [Wertham] In the book "Modern English: A Trendy Slang
Dictionary," Jennifer Blowdryer, a well-known participant
in the Berkeley and San Francisco punk scene, pornography actress
and one-time columnist for Maximum RocknRoll, one of the larger
zines to chronicle the punk scene, completely ignores the zine
press, despite her relatively in-depth coverage of subcultures
serviced by them. Most zines are extremely ephemeral, many not surviving
past the first few issues or changing titles with relative frequency,
and are therefore difficult to study. To simplify things, zines
can then be defined as uncommercial, nonprofessional, small-circulation
magazines produced, published and distributed by their editors.
[Wertham] The word "zine" therefore aptly embodies
the independent magazine press that has become all but invisible
in recent years. Mike Gunderloy,
the founder and long-time editor of Factsheet Five, a zine devoted
to cataloging the zine press and acting as a networking clearing
house, said 90 percent of modern zines fit into one or more of
the following classifications: art (including comics, mail art
and collage), conservative/Constitutionalist, ecological/environmental,
film (horror, sleaze and gore), poetry, religion (pagan, Subgenius,
Discordian and ceremonial magic), anarchist/leftist, music, science
fiction/fantasy, mainstream literary, UFO/Fortean/psychic/odd
science/cranks, peace/anti-war/ socially conscious, and gay/lesbian/bisexual.
[Gunderloy, 1989] In a single issue
of Factsheet Five, Seth Friedman, the current editor, divides
almost 1500 zines into sections including publications labeled
as or covering catalogs, reviews, comics and humor, B movies,
arts and letters, mail art, personal zines, sex, food and health,
spirituality, work, travel, sports, hobby and collecting, science
fiction, technology, community, student, environmental, peace,
leftist and anarchist, libertarian, international news, rants
and cranks, music, punk and queer zines. But the zine press has
not always been so diverse in subject material. According to most
literature on this subject, the first zines focused primarily
on science fiction fandom. Generally considered the first publication
to be called a zine, The Comet began publishing in 1930 and was
basically a science fiction zine composed mostly of articles
on science. Other science fiction zines soon followed, including
Time Traveler and Science Fiction, which was edited by Jerome
Siegel and Joe Shuster, who later became famous as the creators
of Superman. The content of these early zines was characterized
by letter columns (also called lettercols) in which readers debated
and discussed issues concerning science fiction, science articles
and fiction written by amateurs as well as professionals in the
field, columns, reviews of new science fiction book and film
releases, editorials and other features that helped network the
enthusiasts who produced and read the zine. The contributors
who worked to produce zines were usually amateur writers and
artists whose interests centered on science fiction fandom, and
many of these early zines developed from APAzines. APAzines are
produced by a central editor who solicits page submissions from
fans, compiles the pages under one cover and then distributes
the finished product to the initial contributors, members of
the amateur press association (APA) that produced the zine. [Wertham] As science fiction
fandom developed and its audience began to cross over to reading
comic books as well in larger numbers, zines devoted to comic
book fandom closely followed. Like their forerunners, comic zines
grew out of comic APAzines, and many zines combined elements
of the APAzines with more news-oriented content to chronicle
and network comic fandom. One of the more popular comic zines
was Batmania, edited and published by Biljo White during the
1960s. Inspired by Jerry Bails' and Roy Thomas' zine Alter Ego,
also produced during the '60s, White provided a forum for "Batmanians"
all around the world. Many contributors
to and readers of comic zines, including Alter Ego's Roy Thomas,
later went on to work in the field professionally as artists,
writers and even editors. [Gelb] The early comic zines also inspired
people to produce their own comic books, many printed in a smaller
format than mainstream comic books. The minicomic press still
exists today, influenced by comic zines and independent comic
books, although self-publishing can be frustrating and challenging.
[Shires] Zines have been and continue to be influential contributors
to American popular culture as zine producers, like mainstream
periodical producers, help map out the hierarchy of cultural
forms and analysis of pop culture. [Shiach] The networking
and unifying quality of the science fiction and comic zine worlds
can be viewed as parallel to the alternative newspapers that
provide an outlet for the "other voices" not expressed
by the mainstream news. One must still remember, however, that
covering science fiction fandom is far different than covering
African-American communities. Zines have made
great strides in gaining legitimacy and cultural importance as
they have moved away from addressing subjects dealing strictly
with popular culture and have started to cover more relevant
subjects that affect more people. While still documenting a niche
of pop culture, the punk zines of the late 1970s, such as the
defunct Sniffin' Glue, were a crucial step in this direction
and continue to thrive, providing the modern zine press with
a backbone of inspiration. Before launching
into a full-fledged discussion of the punk zine press, it might
be helpful and important to define punk rock itself. As a movement,
punk adopted the same revolutionary ideals held by the early
avant-garde movements: unusual fashions, the view of everyday
life as an abstraction of art, the juxtaposition of unrelated
objects and behaviors, adversarial involvement of the audience
in performances, a general lack of artistic training and the
rejection of accepted modes of performance. [Henry] As a style of music,
punk rock combined elements of the glitter-rock epitomized by
David Bowie, working class London pub-rock, the mod subculture
of the 1960s, southern rhythm and blues, soul music and reggae.
Its loud, fast-paced, jerky rhythms and anti-authoritarian lyrical
content stood in stark contrast with popular mainstream music
and reflected the subculture's members' wishes to escape the
humdrum of acceptable behavior and life. [Hebdige] Drawing on
Andre Breton's Dada movement, the punk press also embodied and
continues to embody the attitudes expressed in the music. continued... return
to mainexternal sites open in new window report new or dead sites here |